Pie Love You!

Best Pizza in America

Made From Scratch

Our New York authentic pies are built to order using homemade recipes from our family archives.

Freshest Ingredients and Traditional Approaches

Our dough and sauces are made fresh, daily using only the best ingredients. Once you taste a My Pie you'll be hooked! Also, these are prepared by recognized chefs, each dish depicts the quality of ingredients and consistent delivery, which is the pride of the management.

Spicy Butcher!

The OG My Pie and fan favorite

Foods are Crafted by Passionate Hands!

With the care and passion that is put into every dish in our restaurant, it is no surprise why so many people have felt satisfied after enjoying our food. From hearty pizzas to scrumptious desserts, we have something for everyone’s palate. Whether you’ve been eating with us for years or are visiting us for the first time, rest assured knowing that each one of our dishes has been meticulously crafted by loving hands. So come visit us soon and join us in partaking in the delicious goodness that we love to create with so much enthusiasm!

Order directly from our website to save money in fees, get faster service, earn free food via our rewards program, and support local business.

Pizza Your Way

At My Pie we pride ourselves in being your neighborhood pizzeria. Our New York authentic pie are built to order using homemade recipes from our family archives. Our motto is local, fresh, fast! We love to source our produce locally and our pies cook up in a New York minute. Our dough and sauces are made fresh, daily using only the best ingredients. Once you taste a My Pie you’ll be hooked! Our quality and flavor far surpass the competition and we’re sure you’ll feel the same way. My Pie is truly a modern classic. It is a place where each guest has the opportunity to custom build their own dining experience.

My Pie & Chill

We’re living in the age of digital streaming! There are so many awesome shows and movies to watch we thought you’d like to take the experience to full sensory happiness with a list of our favorite pizza pairings.

Godzilla vs. King Kong

My Pie pairing: Angry Bird Pizza vs. Pesto My Chicken Pizza

Mortal Kombat

My Pie pairing: Spicy Butcher Pizza

Breaking Bad

My Pie pairing: Mr. White Pizza – I mean, we had too, right?

The Handmaid’s Tale

My Pie pairing: Pizza Your Way – honestly, the freedom to make your own decisions seems key here.

Raya and the Last Dragon

My Pie pairing: We’d love to get super fancy here, but let’s face it. This is a kid’s movie – they’re going to want a plain cheese New York or a Roni Pizza.

My Pie Catering

My Pie Pizza has all of your catering needs covered with fast and affordable options for any sized party or gathering!

Our standard catering package includes the same amazing My Pie pizza, salad, and garlic knots you know and love. And the best part? All are made-to-order for the number of people served. If you want to add other My Pie favorites, such as cookies, other varieties of salad, meatballs, and soda, we’re more than happy to accommodate!

We ask that you contact us at least 24 hours in advance. Your catering order comes with all the utensils you’ll need to serve your group. Catering prices vary depending on the size of your group. If you’re looking for fresh, delicious food to serve at your next event, give My Pie Pizza a call!

If you’re looking for fresh, delicious food to serve at your next event.